Census data for family of David Vining and Betsey Smith

	1840	1850	1860	1870	1880	1890
David Vining	?	?	59	dead
Betsey (Smith) Vining	?	?	53	63	73	dead
James Vining	?	?	26	married and living in separate household
Mahala S. Vining	?	?	married and living in separate household
Maria C. Vining	?	?	24, married and living in this household
David Appleton Vining		?	26 [sic]	26	37	?

1860 Lewiston, Maine (Androscoggin County) - dwelling 213, family 227. Also living in this household in 1860 was Emma M. Perley (2, b. ME), likely the daughter of Maria C. (Vining) Perley.

1870 Lewiston (Ward 7), Maine (Androscoggin County) - dwelling 20, family 22. Also living in this household in 1860 was Sally S. Vining (62, b. ME), likely the unmarried sister of David Vining.

1880 Lewiston, Maine (Androscoggin County) - In 1880 David Appleton Vining was listed as head of household.