Census data for family of David Vining and Gratia/Gracia K. Taylor

	1820	1830	1840	1850	1860	1870
David Vining	?	?	?	?	61	?
Gratia/Gracia K. (Taylor) Vining	?	?	?	?	62	?
David Taylor Vining		?	?	?	married and living in separate household

1860 Hawley, Massachusetts (Franklin County) - dwelling 64, family 66. Also living in this household in 1860 was Martin Vining (63, b. MA), the older brother of Asa Vining and who was reported as "Idiotic". Also living in the same dwelling, but listed as "family 67", was a Sarah Vining (50, b. MA).