Census data for family of Calvin Vining and Mary Ann Noe
  1830 1840 1850 1860 1870 1880
Calvin Vining M 30-40 M 40-50 51 dead

Mary Ann (Noe) Vining F 20-30 F 30-40 45 ? ? ?
    Elias M. Vining M 5-10 M 15-20 married and living in separate household

    Nancy Vining F under 5 F 10-15 not living in this household ? ? ?
    daughter Vining F under 5 F 10-15 not living in this household ? ? ?
    daughter Vining F under 5 F 10-15 not living in this household ? ? ?
    William Vining

M 5-10 17 ? ? ?
    Mary E. Vining

F 5-10 15 ? ? ?
    Phebe Vining

F under 5 13 ? ? ?
    Samuel W. Vining

10 ? ? ?
    Sarah Vining

8 ? ? ?
    Henry Clay Vining

5 ? ? ?
    Isaac Edwin Vining

3 months ? ? married and living in separate household


1830 Bennington, OH (Delaware County)

1840 Bennington, OH (Delaware County)

1850 Bennington, OH (Morrow County) - dwelling 629, famly 642. Also living in this household in 1850 was Sarah Vining (79, b. CT), Calvin Vining's mother.